Journalism

Proofreading Checklist: The 6 Error Types Spellcheck Misses

Readers who spot mistakes question your accuracy on facts they can't verify. Catch what software can't.

By Chandler Supple4 min read

Spelling errors and typos damage credibility instantly. Readers who spot mistakes question your accuracy on facts they cannot verify themselves. Spellcheck catches obvious misspellings but misses homophone errors, autocorrect substitutions, and proper noun mistakes—the most damaging types. Human review remains essential.

6 Error Types Spellcheck Misses

What Automation Can't Catch

# Error Type Example Why Spellcheck Misses It
1Homophones"The counsel voted" (should be council)Both are valid words
2Autocorrect substitutions"Public corruption" → "Public construction"Substituted word is spelled correctly
3Proper nouns"John Smith" vs "Jon Smyth"No dictionary reference
4Wrong real words"form" instead of "from"Both are valid spellings
5Missing words"The committee will the proposal"Remaining words are spelled correctly
6Number transpositions"370%" instead of "37%"Numbers aren't words

Common Homophone Errors

Most Frequent Mistakes

Confused Pair Rule Test
its / it'sit's = it is or it hasSubstitute "it is"—if it works, use it's
their / there / they'rethey're = they are; their = possessiveSubstitute "they are"—if it works, use they're
your / you'reyou're = you areSubstitute "you are"
affect / effectaffect = verb; effect = noun (usually)"The policy will [verb] residents"
council / counselcouncil = governing body; counsel = advice/advisorWho/what is being referenced?
principal / principleprincipal = main or school head; principle = ruleIs it a person or concept?

Proofreading Techniques

6 Methods That Catch Errors

Technique How It Works What It Catches
Read backwardStart with last sentence, work to firstBreaks expectation bias; catches wrong words
Read aloudSpeak every word slowlyMissing words, awkward phrasing
Verify proper nounsCheck names against source documentsMisspelled names, titles, organizations
Double-check numbersCompare to source materialsTransposed digits, wrong units
Fresh eyes reviewHave colleague read before publishingErrors you've become blind to
Time delayWait 30+ minutes before final reviewErrors you skipped when drafting

Proofreading Workflow

  1. Run spellcheck first—catch obvious errors to free attention
  2. Verify all proper nouns—names, organizations, places against sources
  3. Check all numbers—dates, statistics, addresses against source documents
  4. Read backward—sentence by sentence from end to beginning
  5. Read aloud—catch missing words and awkward phrasing
  6. Fresh eyes—have someone else review before publishing

Personal Error Log Template

**My Frequent Errors:**
☐ "form" vs "from"
☐ "it's" vs "its"
☐ [Add your patterns]

**Check every time:**
☐ All names spelled correctly
☐ All numbers match sources
☐ All titles/organizations verified

Frequently Asked Questions About Proofreading

Why doesn't Grammarly catch all errors?

AI tools rely on patterns and context—they can't verify facts. Grammarly won't know if "John Smith" should be "Jon Smyth" or if "37%" should be "73%." Only you can verify proper nouns and numbers against source materials. Use AI for first-pass cleanup, then do manual verification.

How do I catch errors I make repeatedly?

Keep a personal error log and search for your patterns. If you consistently type "form" for "from," add it to your checklist and search for it in every draft. Track patterns over time—self-awareness improves accuracy.

What's the best way to proofread under deadline?

Prioritize high-risk elements: names, numbers, headlines. If time is limited, verify proper nouns and statistics first—these errors are most damaging to credibility. Save stylistic polish for when deadlines allow.

Should I read the whole piece backward?

Sentence by sentence, not word by word. Start with the last sentence, read it fully, then move to the second-to-last. This breaks your brain's tendency to fill in expected words while maintaining enough context to catch errors.

Can AI help with proofreading?

Yes, AI tools like River's Proofreading Assistant flag potential errors including homophones. It identifies words often confused (affect/effect), highlights proper nouns for manual verification, and catches patterns spellcheck misses. Always verify AI suggestions—context matters.

Systematic proofreading protects credibility. Use River's Proofreading Assistant for first-pass error detection, then apply human techniques for what software can't catch.

Chandler Supple

Co-Founder & CTO at River

Chandler spent years building machine learning systems before realizing the tools he wanted as a writer didn't exist. He founded River to close that gap. In his free time, Chandler loves to read American literature, including Steinbeck and Faulkner.

Ready to write better, faster?

Try River's AI-powered document editor for free.

Get Started Free →